Help!!??? pump pumping over | Plumbing Jobs | The Job-board | Plumbers Forums

Welcome to the forum. Although you can post in any forum, the USA forum is here in case of local regs or laws

Discuss Help!!??? pump pumping over in the Plumbing Jobs | The Job-board area at Plumbers Forums

Status
Not open for further replies.

mutley racers

Esteemed
Plumber
Gas Engineer
Subscribed
Messages
5,168
Hey guy's, if you look at the picture i uploaded you can see 3 pump positions A, B, and C.

A is where the pump was but was not working well as was under gravity.

B is where he moved it to but it ended up pumping over F&E cistern.

C, is where he thinks it will solve the problem?

Can you guy's tell me what is wrong and what the solution will be?

Cheers

Leroy
 

Attachments

  • one to use!!.jpg
    one to use!!.jpg
    14.4 KB · Views: 56
Think you need to go back to the drawing board

Pump should have been on heating return

Just up date the system to fully pumped with new cylinder and thermostatic controls as required and the money saved on gas bills can go towards your Technical Drawing classes ;)
 
flow /return depends on system design .but few seem to design system at all just slash it in
 
How many "plumbers" now, know how to design a system??, when you have the likes of wicks and b&q posting on the web utterly useless tables on how to size the rads, which people take as gospel facts, I was taught that even a "Mears" calculator was just a tool to help you get a quick rough answer, and the only way to get the correct answer was to work it out mathematically
 
Yes!

Designing a system is taken as too easy or too hard really. I blame the over use of pumps. :):)

If people where required to design gravity and natural circulation systems we would probably find far better designs coming out.

In point a pump was once classed as a system circulation enhancer, meaning the system was required to circulate through convection without a pump, the pump just enhanced that circulation.

Today the pump seems to do it all.

Not only that, as Migo has said, how often do we hear of corrosion in mixed metal systems or what causes corrosion in water systems?

What about system resistances and a whole lot more. All seem to have been chucked out the window in favour of "Big pump push anywhere" designs.

Plastic pipe laid in like skipping rope, probably would not even circulate without a pump to push it around. But then stepping up the pump increases the water velocity and what effect does that have on steel rads or heat exchangers?

How often are all these factors used in system design?

I suppose at the end of the day its far easier to follow one seemingly successful pattern and follow that.
Then all you need to know are the basics of how it works and adapt it for each job.

But it doesn't always work like that.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
The doing away with properly designed gravity central heating, for an all pumped system in the false name of energy conservation, is another bone of contention with me

I remember on another forum, somebody asking what to do with a sealed system solid fuel (wood) boiler, going full out, and the pump stops, and the boiler starts to dance around the room because the water in the boiler is boiling

I can see in a few years time when solid fuel C/H is making a comeback, all sorts of problems, with ill designed systems

My reasoning is that oil and gas will be a lot more expensive than it is now, people will turn to other fuels, especially wood because of the living fire (people like to see the flame flickering), and electricity will not be a 100% reliable supply, because of the present day lack of building power stations
 
Yes Plouasne, it does seem as though it may go that way. I often wonder why they seem to concentrate more on getting alternative fuels for the motorcar than they do for domestic heating systems. Okay they talk about wind, geo thermal, voltaic, and heat pump alternatives but those programs need drastic up sizing and research for them to be more effective.

Lets be honest, how many heat pumps are fitted compared to gas boilers?

We should be looking for alternative ways of heating domestic premises.

At the moment its all insulation and boiler efficiency based over here.

How about heating the person instead of the house?

How about domestic hydrogen converter units and changing boilers from natural gas to hydrogen burners?

It could perhaps been done on a local scale.

How about burning rubbish for heat? I know its getting done now, but isn't it slow?

We Brits need to stop mucking about and join Europe properly. Mind you the Brit bankers couldn't do what they liked then, and working people would have to work normal hours with proper holidays.
Lets get away from using Brits as cheap labour to undercut the European developed countries like France and Germany.
 
Yes Plouasne, it does seem as though it may go that way. I often wonder why they seem to concentrate more on getting alternative fuels for the motorcar than they do for domestic heating systems. Okay they talk about wind, geo thermal, voltaic, and heat pump alternatives but those programs need drastic up sizing and research for them to be more effective.

Lets be honest, how many heat pumps are fitted compared to gas boilers?

We should be looking for alternative ways of heating domestic premises.

At the moment its all insulation and boiler efficiency based over here.

How about heating the person instead of the house?

How about domestic hydrogen converter units and changing boilers from natural gas to hydrogen burners?

It could perhaps been done on a local scale.

How about burning rubbish for heat? I know its getting done now, but isn't it slow?

We Brits need to stop mucking about and join Europe properly. Mind you the Brit bankers couldn't do what they liked then, and working people would have to work normal hours with proper holidays.
Lets get away from using Brits as cheap labour to undercut the European developed countries like France and Germany.

Bernie,

I agree with you, the much vaunted heat pump air to water for UFH, most now a days have an electric immersion heater in a pocket to top up the heat of the water when the outside temperature drops too low; A CON or what ??

Insulation the regulations are much too slack, I remember reading in I think the carpenter and builder, around 1960, that the Swedes, had triple glazing and 18 inches of insulation even then
A timber frame building, using "I" beams for all the timbers, 30cms in depth with 30cm fibre glass/rock wool insulation in between the timbers (floor, walls, ceiling, roof), with 25mm of the "Dow blue" insulation on the outer shell of the timber frame, 50mm closed air gap, then 150mm light weight concrete block outer skin, the heat loss through this type of construction, is in the region of 0.08 watts/mt²/°c, and for a "bog standard" sized british home it would need a boiler in the region of 4 to 6Kw, couple this with a heat store of 500 to a 1000 litres, with solar panels that's a good 75% saving on fuel, if not more, I would say

France at the moment insists on a minimum of 150mm insulation in the walls for timber frame housing, 200mm in normal block wall houses, and 200mm in the roof, the aim by 2012 is for an annual heat consumption for all heating requirements (heating & hot water), of no more than 50Kw/mt² plan area/year, and by 2015 reduce this to 25Kw/mt² plan area/year; not being nasty or snide now, what's the UK doing

Wood pellet boilers/fires are becoming the in thing, a log fire has always been a feature in 90% of French houses, sometimes a back-boiler coupled to the Oil C/H(red diesel burning 35 sec oil only, in France, they regard Kerosene 28 sec oil as too dangerous, for central heating, and can only be obtained in small lots 20ltr's) 99.9% of the C/H in France is of the sealed system as well, so you can imagine the raised eye brow from me, at first

Hydrogen is a less energy dense fuel and there could be a problem of local generating it, in my opinion

Waste rubbish burning has been long used in France, but then France had a lot of its cities reshaped by both the Germans, the UK and the Allies, and so started of from a better footing, for district heating via waste burning, I believe its the same with Germany

Don't want to shatter your dream, but the wages are fairly low in France, 1500 to 2000€/month (£1275 -£1700/month), but 35 to 40 hour week at least an hour for lunch 90% of the time paid for by the firm, the whole of August of for holiday, down side is Christmas is 1 day off, and the 24th is just a normal working day with maybe a couple of hours off, January 1st is the big day though

Euros and the UK bankers (should that be a "W" instead of a "B"??) do not mix, all that lovely commission they charge to change £ to € and back again would be lost

When is the revolution starting ?? shall I renew my passport ??, that's another sore point with me, the best part of 200€ (£190) to renew it from the Embassy in Paris, plus 10 minuets on a premium phone line at 1€ a min

This will give you some idea of how the other side is tackling the problem

PICT0838.jpg


A 1.20mtr space under the ground floor, the external wall will be timber clad

PICT0840.jpg


The underside of polystyrene block for a block and beam suspended ground floor

PICT0853.jpg


The topside of another property before the slab is cast

PICT0862.jpg


Note the depth of the foundations

PICT0865.jpg


And the thickness of the concrete, the steels sticking up are reinforcing rods, the concrete blocks are hollow and slid over the steel when laid then filled with concrete

Timberframehouse4.jpg


Inside shot of the top photo, the first floor joists are morticed into the central beam and the wall plate on the outer edge, timber uprights are 200mm x 145mm
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar plumbing topics

  • Question
Replies
2
Views
396
B
  • Question
Where is the pump fitted on the Woodburner...
Replies
1
Views
1K
I'm trying to make sense of a system I've came...
Replies
0
Views
868
    • Like
Alpha 2/3 manual. Shows variant with air...
Replies
8
Views
1K
E
I reckon if I did a survey of 100 heating...
Replies
0
Views
466
eco-heating options
E
Back
Top