BOILER NOT HEATING ALL RADIATORS | Boilers | Plumbers Forums
  • Welcome to PlumbersTalk.net

    Welcome to Plumbers' Talk | The new domain for UKPF / Plumbers Forums. Login with your existing details they should all work fine. Please checkout the PT Updates Forum

Welcome to the forum. Although you can post in any forum, the USA forum is here in case of local regs or laws

American Visitor?

Hey friend, we're detecting that you're an American visitor and want to thank you for coming to PlumbersTalk.net - Here is a link to the American Plumbing Forum. Though if you post in any other forum from your computer / phone it'll be marked with a little american flag so that other users can help from your neck of the woods. We hope this helps. And thanks once again.

Discuss BOILER NOT HEATING ALL RADIATORS in the Boilers area at Plumbers Forums

Status
Not open for further replies.
Hi there, looking for some guidance here please.
Running a Baxi Solo boiler, which is located on the 1st floor of 3 storey property. There 17 rads in total 9 of which are on the ground floorbut 3 have never heated up at all. the pump is a SMC gold GP63. The 5 rads on the 1st floor and 2 rads on the top floor all heat up adequately.
Could the pump size be the problem here ?? if so what model/size pump should be installed ?? thanks in advance for your advice Cheers Ted
 
Pump could be weak...isit set on speed 3? A system thst size will need to be balanced adequately. Are the rads that dont heat up the furthest away?
 
It does sound like a pump issue but not necessarily size/duty.
It could be balancing, it could be a partially blocked pump.
 
Most likely needs bigger pump and balancing. 6m head applies against virtually no resistance. Whether it’s up or down it’s still the same beast. Grundfos UPS 25-80 good cost effective solution provided pipe sizing adequate in the first place.
 
You need to know the resistances of the index circuit to work out the pump size. I wouldn't recommend guessing it, you could create more problems.
You need to pay a Heating Engineer to look at this for you in my opinion.
 
Hi thanks for your replies, yes these 3 rads are the furthest away and appear to have been added on 15 years ago when the property was extended. All the pipework seems adequate ie 28mm 22mm 15mm.
The extra rads were all 15mm. so maybe the bigger pump would make sense. Would it be a straight replacement ie,not have to alter anything ?? cheers Ted
 
The 25/80 is slightly longer, i.e. 180mm as opposed to 150mm. So reasonably straightforward for competent person especially if pipework straight and pump at high level, just move pump valve to suit.
 
Good point. Would most likely benefit from sealing (not necessarily pressurising) to avoid air ingress/ pumping over issues as we have no detail of primary pipe work configuration.
 
Means pump upgrade should be a doddle.
 
Every heating system has the same issues with radiators at the end of the line not heating up as good as the ones at the start, especially with inverted systems. I can say for certain that buying a new state of the art 6 meter head pump will not solve your problem. It might improve it slightly for a short time but it will revert back to its present situation again.
To fix it you must first isolate the boiler fluctuation cycle from the radiators. The delta T in the radiators must be reduced significantly. Any competent Plumber that is keeping up to date with heating systems can do this for you.
 
  • Disagree
Reactions: Vee
Hi there, looking for some guidance here please.
Running a Baxi Solo boiler, which is located on the 1st floor of 3 storey property. There 17 rads in total 9 of which are on the ground floorbut 3 have never heated up at all. the pump is a SMC gold GP63. The 5 rads on the 1st floor and 2 rads on the top floor all heat up adequately.
Could the pump size be the problem here ?? if so what model/size pump should be installed ?? thanks in advance for your advice Cheers Ted

Hi, before you go to the expense of buying another pump which may not improve anything, have a go at balancing the system. It really isn't difficult.
To see if it is a balancing problem, shut off all your other rads and see if the cold rads get hot. If they don't then you either have a blockage or the pump isn't man enough to overcome the resistance of the pipework. I would doubt that this is the case.
To balance the system, if you have TRV's take heads off. Start off by shutting all the rads that do get hot to half a turn open on the lockshield valve. The lockshield valves can go through about 4 to 5 turns fully open to closed but you get no regulation (valve authority) until the last turn. If you have any rads that you know heat up very quickly, you can probably set these to a quarter turn open.
You should now have something that resembles a rough balance.
After that it is just a matter of tweaking and rechecking to see what rads are hotter or cooler. Shut the system off and on a few times to see what rads heat up first. Its a bit of running around but and trial and error but like I said its not some great art.
If you have a temperture probe you can check the on and off temps across each radiator. You can get IR non contact guns with laser pointers for under a tenner if you can be bothered to do this. You need to have the same differential across each rad. So if you had one rad with 78c on and 73c off (5c degrees diff) and another that has 80c on and 60c off (20c degrees diff) the rad with the low 5c differential is getting too much flow. The water is traveling too fast to allow the transfer of heat. A 20c degree differential is ideal. This is the differential your boiler is design to work at.
Remember, the radiator that is in the same room as your thermostat wants to be the last one to be able to satisfy the room temp. If this rad is blasting out heat it will activate the stat and shut off the boiler before the other rooms are heated. This rad should never have a TRV fitted for the same reason but to the opposite effect. The rad will shut off and not let the stat operate and the boiler will run on and on until it shuts down through over heating.
If you get your system balanced you can probably turn your boiler down and save some money. Lots of people try to fix a poorly performing system by turning their boiler up.
You might want to check your water quality too. If your system is becoming sludged up the sludge will naturally collect where the water is at its slowest velocity. This will be in your radiators (check if any rads are cold across the bottom) or even in any pipework where the flow is struggling. If this is the case you may need to get you system flushed. I would recommend that you get a company that uses a thermal imaging camera to check that any blocked rads are cleared properly cleared. I've seen the jobs some companies do and it isn't adequate.
 
Ok Thanks for that info.. i will try the shutting off rads and leaving cold ones open and see the effects before buying a different pump.. and get back to you wonderful guardians
 
In post #6 the OP states that the three problem radiators are in an extension, and that they are fed by 15mm pipework. If that 15mm is feeding three large radiators, and even worse if it is tee'd off 15mm feeds to another radiator, it might be that the pipework cannot carry sufficient heat.

Have a look at the size and type of the radiators, and, if possible, whether they are fed of a 22mm / 28mm "spine" or if all feed and return pipework back to the original system is 15mm. If you are trying to heat more than about 8Kw of radiators off 15mm pipework that is likely to be the problem. Only realistic solution would be to increase the size of the pipework.
 
1. Why?
2. How would you do that?


Why?

The water within the boiler is constantly fluctuating in temperature. There is also 7°C to 8°C swing on the boiler temperature between cut in and cut out cycles even with modern modulating boilers. The water in the radiators also fluctuate 4°C to 5°C in temperature every few seconds. It can been clearly seen with the use of a thermal imaging video camera.
The above issues lead to pump resistance and a high delta T, therefore the radiators at the end of the line cannot heat efficiently.
There is an easy to install product available to address the above but unfortunately we are not allowed name specific products on the forum.
 
Fitting a bigger pump to overcome such resistance is cost effective and straightforward.
 
If it was as simple as fitting a larger pump, it would not be an issue as it could easily be sorted. A larger pump would only increase pump cavitation. To fix a problem first you must admit there is a problem and address it overall. At the end of the day all the installer should be concerned about is to have a system operating 100% for their customers, and not their own ego. There is only one way to sort it and that is reduce the delta T, and allow the system to function effortlessly, increasing its overall performance and output and give the customers the system they deserve and pay for.
 
Sounds to me you are a manufacturer trying to flog a gadget posing as a plumber?
 
I am a qualified plumber with 30 years’ experience in the business. I am just fed up with the inefficiencies in heating system. On forums like this every day people keep asking the same questions over and over again and the so called experts keep replying with the same old answers, change the pump, balance the radiators, and the most famous one of all POWER FLUSHING.
We are all around long enough to know that inverted system like this one cannot and will not operate efficiently. This is the reason why people have electric heaters in rooms because there radiators are not working. I do not like to see decent people who are looking for solutions to fix their heating being put to unnecessary expense by only giving them a temporary solution to a never ending problem.
The technology is here so we should embrace it and be glad that the ongoing problems can finally be resolved.
 
So where are you based? What makes your 30 years of experience more valuable than our 30 years? Why can’t you mention your technology if we should all know about it? I hate it when people try to flog expensive wigits or suggest power flushing trying to overcome inherent design problems other than offering practical cost effective solutions, too.
 
As you are aware on forums we are unable to mention products or company names which defeats the purpose really. I am not sure how the forum expect us to find the information but I suppose they want us to do our own research and hope for the best. I can say that my suggestion is not expensive, and is basically the same price as what some companies charge to power flush a system. In fact if something works the cost is irrelevant.
What make my experience unique is that I would not accept balancing, power flushing, bleeding radiators etc. as part of normal practice. I used that experience to source a solution whereas some Plumber’s with the same years of experience are happy to continue on and except these as normal.
 
I thought so. A theorist. And I do not agree with self promotion of this kind in forums. Suppose there are no rules against it in here?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar plumbing topics

You’re 200 miles away - he is there. You’re...
Replies
3
Views
590
M
A large storage combi could feed more than two...
Replies
5
Views
870
Turned out to be a dirty flame eye inside the...
Replies
8
Views
705
Anyway, you can always increase the boiler...
Replies
16
Views
1K
Drain from the lowest point if you’re draining...
Replies
1
Views
902
Deleted member 120897
D
Back
Top