Why wouldn't you fit a new Boiler with a Magnetic Filter?

[berks1234]

Hi,

I've just had new Boiler installed and noticed that they never put in a Magnetic Filter.

I thought that it was standard practice these days?

The installers we used on another installation put in a Magnaclean on the Heating return.

Thanks

 

[Dotty]

Unless it's called for in the manufacturers instructions instructions it doesn't have to be fitted.

Doesn't mean that it's not good practice though.

 

[Leezygeezer]

Did you specify it before the job was completed and did the manufacturer state that one must be fitted? Don't forget there is an additional cost implication, could be the difference between securing the job and losing it to someone else.

Plus, if a system is adequately flushed and treated then any corrosion should be minimal and the need for a filter would be moot anyway

 

[lame plumber]

i dont feel a needto do so on a new system, normally do if it is just a boiler swap on an old system, makes for a longer lasting boiler

 

[plumben]

As above unless stated necessary in the Mi's you dont need to fit one but is best practice, as the customer if you expect one to be fitted you should state that at the time of the quote/estimate
although its not difficult to fit one after the install

 

[townfanjon]

Its building regs say one should be fitted , I advise customer to have one , but the odd one says no .

 

[Masood]

Its building regs say one should be fitted

Really? I didn't know that. Thought it was just good practice, not yet a requirement...

 

[berks1234]

I have heard somewhere that it comes under the Building Regs on new installs.

They fitted one as standard on another full CH system that we had put in elsewhere.

The problem is that they didn't state that one was being supplied in the materials fee.

But they again, I don't really know what parts were supposed to be in there, apart from the number of rads and copper.

These things can be easily overlooked or assumed to be part of the complete package.

Should I ask them to install one before they commission the system?

Thanks

 

[tamz]

Its building regs say one should be fitted , I advise customer to have one , but the odd one says no .

No they don't

 

[tamz]

To the OP.
You just noticed they never put in a filter or did you neglect to notice it wasn't mentioned on the quote.

 

[plumben]

I have heard somewhere that it comes under the Building Regs on new installs.

They fitted one as standard on another full CH system that we had put in elsewhere.

The problem is that they didn't state that one was being supplied in the materials fee.

But they again, I don't really know what parts were supposed to be in there, apart from the number of rads and copper.

These things can be easily overlooked or assumed to be part of the complete package.

Should I ask them to install one before they commission the system?

Thanks

It will be very quick and easy to fit one if theres no water in the system yet, but there will be the added cost obviously but if theres water and Inhibitor In the system the drain down fit and re inhibit the system might cost a bit more

 

[REDSAW]

buy one and ask them to fit it f.o.c if you really want one!
sorted

 

[tamz]

Not really. Sealed system drop the pressure and cut it in. 10 minutes work and no need to top up inhibitors as you only lost a few litres.
Not everyone will do that tho.

 

[tamz]

buy one and ask them to fit it f.o.c if you really want one!
sorted

Lol

 

[hammers4spanner]

To the OP.
You just noticed they never put in a filter or did you neglect to notice it wasn't mentioned on the quote.

More than likely the case

 

[townfanjon]

No they don't

I stand to be corrected , but I have read it somwhere

 

[berks1234]

Please see the mfr recommendations below at the end...

NB. Bearing in mind that this a new complete new system with rads and pipes etc.

But, we've just the other CH system serviced in the other property, and that Magaclean had picked up quite a bit of sediment within 12 months. And that was a brand new installation, boiler, rads, and pipes.

The MFR instructions say.

▶ Remove a little water from the heating circuit.
▶ Check the appearance of the heating water.
▶ If you ascertain that it contains sedimentary materials,
you must desludge the system.
▶ Use a magnetic rod to check whether it contains magnetite
(iron oxide).
▶ If you ascertain that it contains magnetite, clean the system
and apply suitable corrosion-protection measures, or
fit a magnet filter.
▶ Check the pH value of the removed water at 25 °C.
▶ If the value is below 6.5 or above 8.5, clean the system
and treat the heating water.

 

[Masood]

Please see the mfr recommendations below at the end...

NB. Bearing in mind that this a new complete new system with rads and pipes etc.

But, we've just the other CH system serviced in the other property, and that Magaclean had picked up quite a bit of sediment within 12 months. And that was a brand new installation, boiler, rads, and pipes.

The MFR instructions say.

▶ Remove a little water from the heating circuit.
▶ Check the appearance of the heating water.
▶ If you ascertain that it contains sedimentary materials,
you must desludge the system.
▶ Use a magnetic rod to check whether it contains magnetite
(iron oxide).
▶ If you ascertain that it contains magnetite, clean the system
and apply suitable corrosion-protection measures, or
fit a magnet filter.
▶ Check the pH value of the removed water at 25 °C.
▶ If the value is below 6.5 or above 8.5, clean the system
and treat the heating water.

What's your point? Manufacturer's instructions say either clean and inhibit, OR fit a filter. Not a requirement to fit, but an option.

 

[Millsy 82]

I generally fit one on every installation but if there is a budget I need to squeeze into then it would be one of the first things to go.

Did you get a few quotes/estimates?

 

[SmokeyJ]

Filter always goes down as a additional option on our quotes. Leaves it up to the customer to decide (never had a customer reject the filter). If it's just included in the price it may be the difference in actually getting the job. Imo i'd say it's not good practice to not even give the option for a filter.
I can see filters being standard practice in the future.

 

[TVP&H Ltd]

I stand to be corrected , but I have read it somwhere

I'm with you on this one.. I have also read, and been told that it is a part of building regs.

 

[townfanjon]

I'm with you on this one.. I have also read, and been told that it is a part of building regs.

Lol , cheers I thought I had gone daft , they seem to keep ading bits to part L .

I always fit them anyway , only once a customer said no .

 

[TVP&H Ltd]

I always fit one as they are required for extended warranty's. Its also the easiest way for some manufacturer's to walk away.
I've been to service boilers on a 1yr old property and found the filter has collected a fair bit of magnetite.

 

[newcastle phill]

I always fit one when the customer pays for one

 

[REDSAW]

filter is a £100 option that is and never will be a part included within the boiler purchase!
if it were compulsory, then all boiler manufacturers would include one within the boiler to their own spec.
that also includes trv's and controls.
however, water softners have more requirement from the boiler manufaturers instructions to be fitted inline.