System or Combi in local pub? | Central Heating Forum | Page 2 | Plumbers Forums

  • Welcome to PlumbersTalk.net

    Welcome to Plumbers' Talk | The new domain for UKPF / Plumbers Forums. Login with your existing details they should all work fine. Please checkout the PT Updates Forum

Welcome to the forum. Although you can post in any forum, the USA forum is here in case of local regs or laws

American Visitor?

Hey friend, we're detecting that you're an American visitor and want to thank you for coming to PlumbersTalk.net - Here is a link to the American Plumbing Forum. Though if you post in any other forum from your computer / phone it'll be marked with a little american flag so that other users can help from your neck of the woods. We hope this helps. And thanks once again.

System or Combi in local pub?

Post thread
Post reply

Discuss System or Combi in local pub? in the Central Heating Forum area at Plumbers Forums

That would imply they’re in series and not parallel.
You say you’re confident the boiler is powerful enough and you might be right and a 25/80 pump is huge, should be more than enough. You also say this system has always been troublesome which leads me to question what size pipe work has been used. If you’ve always had problems getting energy to the furthest rads it might be the pipework is too small to carry the required load.
 
Are you able to post some pictures?
It’s going to help if you want suggestions on a way to improve things.
If it’s never worked properly it may need a repipe
 
JohnHuson said:
No, there is the pump in the combi boiler and a 25/80 pump installed in the heat output line to push the hot water to the central heating system. My limited knowledge says it needs one pump for each zone as suggested? Should the pumps be on the supply or return?
Click to expand...

The problem is the boiler pump is adjustable and isn’t fixed also your boiler is limited in regards to lpm output so your external pumps needs separation which I think will fix your problem
 
ShaunCorbs said:
The problem is the boiler pump is adjustable and isn’t fixed also your boiler is limited in regards to lpm output so your external pumps needs separation which I think will fix your problem
Click to expand...
I’m not convinced separation will solve his problem. We both know it’s needed anyway but I still suspect there’s a problem on what would be the secondary side.
IF the boiler is suitably sized and separation is installed be it CCT’s or a LLH then there should be no mixing as the flow rates should be equal on primary and secondary. There has been no mention of UFH etc. A 25/80 is huge and I assume 8m head? That should be more than enough to cover even an abnormally large index circuit, yet they’re still complaining of Luke warm radiators at the moment.
I still maintain they should have the building and current pipework system surveyed. Without knowing the boiler output required and the current system configuration no engineer can accurately say this is the fix or that’s the fix. Once you have a picture of the current system (which I suspect was never designed properly at the start) then you can give them their options. There’s nothing saying the combi couldn’t stay in place and have a separate HW cylinder but with what little information we have all we are doing is just guessing, regardless of how experienced and competent I know we are.
 
SJB060685 said:
I’m not convinced separation will solve his problem. We both know it’s needed anyway but I still suspect there’s a problem on what would be the secondary side.
IF the boiler is suitably sized and separation is installed be it CCT’s or a LLH then there should be no mixing as the flow rates should be equal on primary and secondary. There has been no mention of UFH etc. A 25/80 is huge and I assume 8m head? That should be more than enough to cover even an abnormally large index circuit, yet they’re still complaining of Luke warm radiators at the moment.
I still maintain they should have the building and current pipework system surveyed. Without knowing the boiler output required and the current system configuration no engineer can accurately say this is the fix or that’s the fix. Once you have a picture of the current system (which I suspect was never designed properly at the start) then you can give them their options. There’s nothing saying the combi couldn’t stay in place and have a separate HW cylinder but with what little information we have all we are doing is just guessing, regardless of how experienced and competent I know we are.
Click to expand...

Agreed but I suspect the boiler pump is fighting the fixed speed pump, the fixed speed pump is pulling the combi pump eg increasing the speed so the boiler is having a hard time as the water is flowing too fast through the hex or the other way round the boiler is strangling the 25-80
 
ShaunCorbs said:
Agreed but I suspect the boiler pump is fighting the fixed speed pump, the fixed speed pump is pulling the combi pump eg increasing the speed so the boiler is having a hard time as the water is flowing too fast through the hex or the other way round the boiler is strangling the 25-80
Click to expand...
Exactly the problem with pumps in series yes. A quick measure of the ΔT across the boiler would give you an idea of which.
 
JohnHuson said:
In hindsight the old system only needed one pump to service the whole two zones, Now it has two.
Click to expand...
Irrespective of the rad sizes, if they are not getting hot then no room heat.
You say 40mm piping, a system with a 42kw boiler with a rad dT of 12C will require a flow rate of 50LPM, 3.0M3/Hr, even if all the rads were located at the very end of a 50M run (100M total) the pipe friction losses are ~ 3M, a 8M pump will flow 50LPM @ a 6M head and assuming the boiler pump is similar to a UPS3, this pump will flow 50LPM @ a 2.8M head, maybe be worth looking at the boiler hx loss at a flow of 50 LPM, also condition of 40mm piping.
 
Last Plumber said:
You need a commercial heating engineer to assess it properly in my opinion. There are a number of things that need looking at in order to decide what might be a suitable boiler.
The 23 rads could be any size and so could the pipework so you can't tell anything off that.
The building may be under 42 Kw but is that the heating output or output to hot water?
Click to expand...
The NCB-40LWDE shows 40kw to hot water & 33kw to heating.
Also requires external E.vessel as only 6 liter internally.

1648403117201.png
 
John.g said:
Irrespective of the rad sizes, if they are not getting hot then no room heat.
You say 40mm piping, a system with a 42kw boiler with a rad dT of 12C will require a flow rate of 50LPM, 3.0M3/Hr, even if all the rads were located at the very end of a 50M run (100M total) the pipe friction losses are ~ 3M, a 8M pump will flow 50LPM @ a 6M head and assuming the boiler pump is similar to a UPS3, this pump will flow 50LPM @ a 2.8M head, maybe be worth looking at the boiler hx loss at a flow of 50 LPM, also condition of 40mm piping.
Click to expand...

To clarify, the extra 25/80 pump has been installed in the heat output line from the boiler so
it sucks from the boiler pump? Does that sound stupid? The boiler pump and the new pump send the pressure to the two zones via the 42mm pipework in the loft down to the rads below. I think that there was always a problem with the Concorde Boiler in getting the furthest rads hot.
 
Yes so In series
 
JohnHuson said:
To clarify, the extra 25/80 pump has been installed in the heat output line from the boiler so
it sucks from the boiler pump? Does that sound stupid? The boiler pump and the new pump send the pressure to the two zones via the 42mm pipework in the loft down to the rads below. I think that there was always a problem with the Concorde Boiler in getting the furthest rads hot.
Click to expand...
The pumps as you describe are in series and this can cause a number of problems. Some means of separation is needed and I explained what that is in an above comment.
There’s only so much we can advise you through a website on a phone or laptop etc and we have. You need to contact several reputable firms both qualified and experienced in these scenarios and explain your problem and the advise you’ve had here.
 
JohnHuson said:
To clarify, the extra 25/80 pump has been installed in the heat output line from the boiler so
it sucks from the boiler pump? Does that sound stupid? The boiler pump and the new pump send the pressure to the two zones via the 42mm pipework in the loft down to the rads below. I think that there was always a problem with the Concorde Boiler in getting the furthest rads hot.
Click to expand...

Its certainly unconventional but I'd venture that there are systems with pumps installed like this and working OK, as pointed out above, two different head pumps in "series" may cause one to fight the other, they are really not in series in accepted pump jargon where both pumps are installed one immediately behind the other, but generally one would then install one pump with the required head.
In your case, the boiler circ pump pumps from the return, through the boiler Hx and then supplies the 8M pump.
I would suggest trying to establish what the flow rate is from other data to hand, the boiler flow and return temps and the boiler output, is all you need but these three values arn't often available from the boiler display but the flow/return temps can be measured on the pipes which will give some info at any rate, the boiler output is more difficult but if both zones are open then maybe can get a good idea. If that 8m pump displays its power in watts? (W) then flow rate can be derived exactly, from the pump curves.
 
Thank you for all the responses. They are waiting for a Navien engineer to attend to replace
the heat exchanger under guarantee? Why does that need replacing?
In the meantime the boiler pressure can only be supplied if the cold water pressure supply is
being balanced by the pressure valve constantly sending cold water supply to the outflow
resulting in hundreds of gallons being wasted every day. I thought it was a local offence
to waste water? it is the only way he can get heating in the pub.
What a mess.
 
Are you saying that the Boiler PRV (safety valve) is lifting at 3 bar and discharging water which then has to be replaced with cold water?
 
Are you now saying the plate heat exchanger for HW has failed and the PRV is lifting?
If so then yes you will be losing water but hundreds of gallons a day I highly doubt.
This seems to be getting worse and worse. You need a reputable engineer to go over the whole system. I’m not going to read or comment on this thread further. We’ve given you the advice you need, you now need to get someone out who actually knows a thing or two.
 
John.g said:
Are you saying that the Boiler PRV (safety valve) is lifting at 3 bar and discharging water which then has to be replaced with cold water?
Click to expand...
Yes, stupid isn't it! They are going to replace the heat exchanger so it seems. Several seals have burst causing water leaks since installation. What mess. I find it difficult to accept the inept performance and lack of knowledge from the installers.
 
Do you absolutely know that the "bursting" seals are on the central heating side ?, strange, because if so, the boiler PRV, in lifting at 3bar, should prevent just such a occurance, if the problem is coming from the DHW side then it would mean a extremely high mains pressure which hasn't a pressure reducing valve (PRV) installed.
 
John.g said:
Its certainly unconventional but I'd venture that there are systems with pumps installed like this and working OK, as pointed out above, two different head pumps in "series" may cause one to fight the other, they are really not in series in accepted pump jargon where both pumps are installed one immediately behind the other, but generally one would then install one pump with the required head.
In your case, the boiler circ pump pumps from the return, through the boiler Hx and then supplies the 8M pump.
I would suggest trying to establish what the flow rate is from other data to hand, the boiler flow and return temps and the boiler output, is all you need but these three values arn't often available from the boiler display but the flow/return temps can be measured on the pipes which will give some info at any rate, the boiler output is more difficult but if both zones are open then maybe can get a good idea. If that 8m pump displays its power in watts? (W) then flow rate can be derived exactly, from the pump curves.
Click to expand...
Thank you for all your input. It is appreciated. The system is still under performing. Now waiting for Navien engineers assessment of the situation. This should not be so when the customer has spent £3000 with professionals?
 
New posts

Similar plumbing topics

I
Smart TRV system needed, any advice?
Thanks for all above. I've done a few Evohomes...
Replies
5
Views
681
IND_Nick
I
T
Whether to power flush a 40 year old central heating system?
What did you do in the end? Would be...
Replies
8
Views
2K
jh2254
J
J
Central heating not circulating after New Navien Combi fitted to Santon Premier system.
Thanks.
2 3 4
Replies
76
Views
6K
JohnHuson
J
F
Constant Lockout issue with Ideal Concord CXS/SD40/H
Thanks some good ideas. Just as an aside if we...
Replies
10
Views
2K
FozzieBear
F
I
Combi or unvented System?
If you have the space and money get an...
Replies
5
Views
2K
Scott_D
Scott_D
Back
Top