CH not stopping, Honeywell V4073 + GREENSTAR 12Ri | Plumbing Jobs | The Job-board | Plumbers Forums

Welcome to the forum. Although you can post in any forum, the USA forum is here in case of local regs or laws

Discuss CH not stopping, Honeywell V4073 + GREENSTAR 12Ri in the Plumbing Jobs | The Job-board area at Plumbers Forums

Status
Not open for further replies.
T

TonyK81

Hi all,

Well, here's my situation. We moved into a new place just a while ago, and we can't make the CH + HW system work correctly. Since we're new in the place, I can't tell if it was working properly before or not (oh, we had to replace the SCR at the very beginning). Here are the facts:

Compartments:
- Honeywell ST400C main controller
- Digistat SCR + RF3 wireless thermostat controller
- Honeywell V4073 3-way valve
- L641A Cylinder Stat
- Worcester Greenstar 12Ri boiler
- Grundfos pump

So, what happens at the moment is that the CH does not turn off. Assume everything starts from scratch. We just switch the power on, and all the controllers have HW + CH to OFF. Switch the ST400C CH to continuous, while Digistat thermostat is lower than room temperature. A red light turns on on the ST400C controller, but nothing happens. That's ok. We set the room thermostat higher than the current temperature, signal is sent and accepted, CH turns on (v4073 does it's thing, boiler fires up and the pump starts pushing the water). So far so good.

But once we turn the temperature down, the SRC gets the signal (and green light goes off), but the boiler and the pump keep going, and going, and going... I understand that they are not supposed to stop immediately, but they don't stop at all either! Interesting enough, the valve is still in the "CH on" position.

Troubleshooting:
While playing around, and after a gas engineer had a look at it, we figured out that once the CH has been turned off by the thermostat (but practically still going), if we turn on the HW, wait for a while, and then turn HW off, the valve responds to both and finally stops the CH (along with the HW of course).
It was suggested that the valve was malfunctioning, something about the microswitches. I replaced the valve motorized controller myself (I left the previous pipes), replaced the 5 wires exactly where the previous ones were. But annoyingy enough, same problem exists!

In the valve documentation there was the Y plan. I also searched the boiler plan, which made the whole wiring schema a bit different than what the Y plan suggested, since the pump is directly connected to the boiler, and both receive a "Live" signal from the valve Orange wire, or the Cylinder stat.
As far as I can tell, all connections look OK (though I admit they are a bit complicated). Only things I can't confirm is some wires coming from the Cylinder Stat or the ST400C, which in the Y plan are mentioned with numbers, while all i can see is the cable colours. But by following what should be connected with what, I don't see something wrong.. (also assuming it was "kinda" working for the previous owners, I assume it can't be all that wrong!)

Now, I also read that the Orange wire is supposed to have 240V or 100V everytime there is demand for CH only or CH+HW, respectively. I don't have a multimeter, unfortunately.

My question is, what could be that wrong that if HW is off, and CH is switched off, how come the Orange wire still sends a Live signal in the pump and boiler? Since both motorized valves behaved the same, I'm inclinced to believe there is a problem with the wiring. But can't see something wrong with it, at least not as much as I can tell. I'm not a professional, I have to point this out.

Any help, suggestions or even intuitions, are well appreciated.

Sorry for the long message! I hope my description was not too confusing. Feel free to ask for clarifications if needed.
Thanks
 
The operation of a mid position valve is quite hard to explain but you need to check the wiring more. It has nothing to do with the microswitches inside the valve and you will need a multimeter to test it.
If the heating turns off when there is no demand for hot water ie the valve is in the ch position (farthest away) the valve will remain held in that position as the motor is being powered through the gray wire from the HW off on the programmer. No other valve wire should have power at this point. If the orange still has 240v it is being fed from somewhere else.
The orange wire will have 240v any time there is a demand. There will never be a reduced voltage on it.
The gray wire will have a reduced voltage when the valve is in the mid position.
 
I intend to get a multimeter, to check the voltage at the grey/white/orange cable, which I will post here, in case it helps.

After playing around a bit more I realized that it's kinda non-deterministic.... In 2-3 cases, when the HW was continuously on (but there was no actual demand, since the HW temperature inside the tank was satisfying), I switched the CH on, and after a while then off. And it worked. It took 1-2 minutes for the boiler and pump to stop, but it did stop and radiators started cooling off. Tried it again half an hour later, and the boiler/pump kept on going, even more than 5min after I set it to stop. So it's a mystery to me why the boiler/pump keep going sometimes. I need to check that orange cable I guess.

Having said that, anyone knows what's the usual amount of time that the boiler/pump keep going after the CH is set to off? I understand that it's not supposed to happen immediately. And what controls that logic? Is it the valve that maintains the voltage on the orange wire after it's been told to stop? Or is it the boiler/pump that respond to Orange=0V only after a couple of minutes have passed by?

Another interesting question. Is the valve supposed to ever go in A-only position? Looking at the black ball inside while I play with the manual lever (I can do that since I now got a spare valve), it doesn't seem to ever rotate at a place where B pipe is completely blocked. So, it seems to be going to AB, or B only. Is that normal?

Thanks again
 
When the motorised valve head is off does the valve move freely and not jamming?
 
yeah, I can move it from side to side with my hand. Though I'm not sure if the degrees are exactly the same as with the new one. I'd say that the movement from one side to the other seems to be slightly less than the one I got in my hand. But this may be just my idea.

But even if the valve does not fully close A or B.. still don't understand why the boiler and pump keep getting a Live signal. It wouldn't really make much difference if pipe A was left slightly open, if the boiler and pump stopped anyway (at least not when there is no demand for HW).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar plumbing topics

it already IS (and always has been) a W-plan...
2 3 4
Replies
77
Views
3K
Thanks for the input on this, much...
Replies
4
Views
988
  • Question
OK thanks for the response. I hadn't...
Replies
5
Views
834
Fitted a Drayton LP822, it even used the same...
Replies
6
Views
909
John Thank you for all your help, changed the...
Replies
13
Views
2K
Back
Top